Meet the Team

buth rutherford_2Butch Rutherford ( is Vice President and Agency Manager for Bankers Title Shenandoah. He has been with Bankers Title Shenandoah since its inception in May 1997. He has over 23 years of combined experience in banking and the title insurance industry. Prior to joining Bankers Title Shenandoah, Butch held the position of Vice President and branch manager at a lending institution in Front Royal, VA. He is a licensed title agent and also has his realtor’s license. He is a native of Front Royal, VA.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  .

Andrea Butler_social mediaAndria Butler ( is a Licensed Title Underwriter in Virginia. She joined the Bankers Title Shenandoah team in January of 2007. Andria worked with a land developer and as a loan officer prior to joining Bankers Title Shenandoah. She has lived in the Shenandoah Valley her whole life and continues to enjoy this area with her daughter.                                                                                                                                                                                         .


Lori Messer ( Lori is a Settlement Processor and Post-Closer for Bankers Title Shenandoah. She is a graduate from Mary Baldwin College with a degree in Psychology. Lori has worked in various fields of real estate for the past 14 years.  She lives in Staunton with her husband Mike who is a cattle farmer along with her two cats, Reese and Max and dog, Oliver. Lori also has two adult step children, Sawyer and Anna.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         .

Susan Miller ( Susan Miller is a Settlement Processor and Closer for Bankers Title Shenandoah. She joined the Bankers Title Shenandoah team in April 2016.  Susan has worked in the Real Estate business for over 10 years.  She is responsible for coordinating and performing all aspects of residential and commercial closings.  She currently resides in the Staunton area with her daughter Madeline.